Shading shows form. Light falls on a surface, some parts face the light and stay bright, and others turn away and fall into shadow. In digital art, you can build that pattern on separate layers and adjust each one without repainting the rest. This guide covers the key terms, a workflow you can follow on any subject, and the common mistakes that make shading look flat.
Key terms for shading
- Lit side: The part of a form that faces the light source.
- Terminator: The line where the lit area turns into shadow. A nearby light usually gives a sharper terminator, and a distant or diffuse light gives a softer one.
- Core shadow: The darkest part of the form, usually where it turns away from the light.
- Cast shadow: The shadow an object throws onto another surface.
- Reflected light: Light that bounces from nearby surfaces into the shadow side. It keeps shadows from looking like flat black.
- Contact shadow: A small, dark area where two surfaces meet and light has trouble reaching.
Set up before you shade
Decide where the light comes from before you paint. Everything you shade should respond to that one source. If you change direction partway through, check every shadow again.
Start with a flat base color on its own layer. Put your shadow layers above it and clip them to that base, using a clipping mask or your app’s equivalent, such as alpha inheritance in Krita. Clipped shadows stay inside the shape, so you do not have to paint carefully around edges.
Work in grayscale or a single hue while you set values. Color can hide value problems. When the values read well, add color.
A simple shading workflow
The steps below use a sphere or a simple character as an example. The same logic applies to other forms.
Lay out the core shadow
On a clipped layer set to Multiply, paint the shadow side in a mid-dark tone. Hide and show the layer to check that the shape reads as three-dimensional. If it looks flat, the shadow is probably too small or too evenly spread.
Place the terminator
Paint the lit area on a separate light layer. Use a soft brush or a light tone, and follow the form’s curve. The terminator is the boundary between your light and shadow, so it should follow the shape, not cut straight across it.
Soften the falloff
Blend the terminator where the form curves gradually. Keep it crisper where the form turns quickly or where a hard edge is needed. A soft brush at low opacity works well for this. Avoid blurring everything. Soft and hard transitions together read as more realistic than one uniform softness.
Add the cast shadow
Paint the shadow an object casts onto the ground or onto another surface on a Multiply layer. Its direction should match the light source you chose. Make the edge softer the farther it is from the object that casts it. A shadow that is sharp at the object and soft at its far edge looks natural.
Add contact shadows
Put contact shadows on their own layer, so you can control their strength without changing the core shadow. Use a darker tone and paint close to the points where objects meet. They anchor objects to surfaces.
Add reflected light
On the shadow side, paint a lighter, slightly warm or cool tone along the edge closest to the environment. Use a Screen or Add layer depending on your app. Keep reflected light weaker than the main light, and keep it away from the terminator, or the form will lose its shape.
Adjust opacity
Lower the opacity of shadow and light layers until the balance feels right. Opacity is a quick way to tune strength without repainting. Check the result in grayscale again.
Shadow color and hue
Pure black in shadows often looks dead. Most artists shift the hue of their shadows instead. A cooler shadow is a common choice under warm light, and a warmer one can work under cool light, but this depends on the scene. Treat it as a starting point, not a rule.
Keep shadow saturation under control. Very saturated shadows can look artificial, especially on skin and fabric. A shadow should be a different hue from the base color, not just a darker version of it.
Shading styles
Different styles use shading differently:
- Cel (hard-edged) shading: Flat tones with crisp boundaries between them. It is common in anime and comic art, where forms are read through a small number of distinct tones. See the cel shading guide.
- Soft or airbrushed shading: Smooth gradients with few visible edges. It suits realistic and semi-realistic work.
- Painterly shading: Visible brushwork, with light and shadow built from textured strokes. It suits loose, expressive pieces.
Choose the style that fits the look you want. You can mix styles in one piece, for example cel shading on a character and soft shading on a background, but keep the light direction the same across both.
Common mistakes
- Uniform edges everywhere. Every transition is equally soft, so nothing stands out. Vary edge sharpness by where the form turns.
- Contradictory light. A highlight on one side and a shadow on the same side makes the form hard to read.
- Stacked shadow layers. Many layers of shadow can build into a muddy tone. Keep the number of shadow layers small and check the result.
- No cast shadows. Objects look as if they are floating. Add a cast shadow and a contact shadow.
- Black as the default dark. Using pure black for the darkest areas flattens color and value. Shift the hue instead.
More problems and fixes are covered in the common digital painting mistakes guide.
Practice exercise
Shade a sphere, a cube, and a cylinder under a single light source, all on separate layers. Then shade the same three forms under two lights and notice how the shadow shapes change. Once those read well, apply the same steps to a character. The rendering guide covers what to do with materials after the shading is set, and the lighting setups guide explores more light arrangements.