Choosing Software

Is Procreate or Adobe Illustrator better?

Neither app is better for everything. Procreate suits pixel painting on iPad, while Illustrator suits vector work that must scale. Here is how to choose.

On this page
  1. Vectors or pixels: the decision that matters
  2. Procreate for painting and sketching
  3. Illustrator for iPad for vector design
  4. Interface and ease of use
  5. Gestures and workflow
  6. Exporting and file management
  7. Which one should you choose?

Neither app is better for everything. Procreate is a raster (pixel) painting and sketching app for iPad. Adobe Illustrator is a vector design app, built for logos, icons, and artwork that must scale without losing sharpness. The decision depends mainly on whether your work needs to be enlarged, and by how much.

Vectors or pixels: the decision that matters

Vector graphics are built from mathematical paths, so they scale to any size without losing quality. Raster graphics are made of pixels, so they have a fixed resolution. Enlarge them too far and the edges go soft.

Procreate creates raster art, which suits painting, textures, and soft shading. Illustrator creates vector art, which suits logos, icons, and clean shapes. Vector art is more flexible for resizing, while raster art gives you more freedom with brushes and colour mixing.

Plan your canvas before you start. In Procreate, set the size to the largest output you need. In Illustrator, artboards let you set several sizes in one file. Switching between vector and raster later takes extra work, so decide early.

Procreate for painting and sketching

Procreate has a large brush library, and its brushes feel natural with an Apple Pencil. You can tune brushes in Brush Studio, use layer blend modes and masks, and record time-lapse videos of your process.

Its limits are real. Procreate runs only on iPad, with a separate app for iPhone. Layer limits depend on canvas size and device memory. It is not built for precise geometric work or for scaling artwork up for print.

Procreate’s animation tools in the main app are lighter than those of dedicated animation software. Procreate also offers a separate animation app, Procreate Dreams, for motion work.

Illustrator for iPad for vector design

Illustrator for iPad is the iPad version of Adobe’s vector program. If you know the desktop app, its tools will feel familiar. The Pen tool, Shape Builder, artboards, and alignment tools are all there, and you can move files between the iPad and desktop versions.

It also has trade-offs. It is a subscription. Some desktop features are missing from the iPad version, and one reviewer noted that some effects, such as certain blur and drop-shadow options, are not available. The iPad app runs only on iPad. Adobe Illustrator Draw, an older free app, has been discontinued. Check the current feature list before you commit to a workflow.

Interface and ease of use

Procreate’s screen is minimal. Two rows of tools sit at the top, with sliders for brush size and opacity. Most settings are in menus, which can feel crowded for beginners.

Illustrator for iPad uses a toolbar, a side panel, and floating windows you can rearrange. An in-app tour helps new users. Both apps let you switch controls between the left and right sides, and both offer light and dark modes.

Gestures and workflow

Both apps use a two-finger tap to undo and a three-finger tap to redo. Procreate supports Apple Pencil gestures and has hover features on some newer iPad Pro models. Illustrator has a Touch Shortcut, which changes how a tool behaves while you hold it, for example to constrain shape proportions.

Exporting and file management

Procreate exports .procreate, PSD, PDF, JPEG, PNG, and TIFF, plus animation formats. Its Gallery view groups files into stacks. Page Assist helps with comics and multi-page documents.

Illustrator exports SVG, PDF, PNG, JPG, and PSD, and it can export selected artboards. Files save to Adobe Creative Cloud automatically, and you can share them with other Adobe apps. Procreate depends more on iCloud backups and manual saving to the Files app, so set up backups early.

Which one should you choose?

  • Choose Procreate for sketching, painting, textures, and comics, when you do not need to scale the work much.
  • Choose Illustrator for iPad for logos, icons, and vector art that must scale, or if you already work in Illustrator on the desktop.
  • Use both if you sketch and paint in Procreate and finish vector work in Illustrator. Adobe Fresco can mix pixels and vectors, but reviews describe the results as mixed.

For a painting app comparison that stays on iPad, see Clip Studio Paint vs Procreate. For a desktop vector and raster comparison, see Inkscape vs Krita. The digital art on a computer guide covers the wider set of options.

The complete guide to choosing software

Digital Art on a Computer: Choosing Your Drawing Software
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →